Jamaica in “1984”


In 1949 the dystopian novel “1984”, written by George Orwell, was published.  I can only assume that at the time of its publication it brought to one’s imagination a society so far-fetched in its ideals and practices.  Perhaps no one could ever conceptualize a society in which one’s thoughts and activities were policed and subjected to such keen and intrusive government surveillance.  It would be hard to imagine a place where independent thinking is a crime, dissent is subjected to punishment and persecution, and only love and obedience for “The Party” is rewarded.

In the brouhaha that unfolded in the United States concerning whistleblower Edward Snowden, Orwell’s “1984” regained popularity, and it is during that period of time that I first read the book in its entirety.  At the very least, I was amazed at the prophetic nature of the novel.  But now, considering events unfolding in my own country, I am becoming increasingly concerned.

Firstly, we heard Prime Minister Portia Simpson Miller suggesting that the Opposition Leader may be “an enemy of the state” for comments he made raising concerns about the state of the economy.  We heard expressions tossed around about Jamaicans who criticize the state of governance as being “unpatriotic” and “anti-Jamaica”.

Then last week we saw Minister of Youth and Culture, Lisa Hanna, referring the matter of a petition by civic group Jamaicans for Justice to the Attorney General for review – branding their petition as “disingenuous, dishonest, dangerous and clearly designed to damage the reputation of this country” (Jamaica Gleaner – July 18, 2013).  Right on the heels of this we have government MP Raymond Pryce putting forward a motion for civic groups and NGO’s to be registered and audited because of concerns regarding “…unknown donors with unspecified agendas…”  He said, “…many times, they can receive funds in a subversive way that has hidden agendas, and many times those sources of funds come from agencies that are inimical to the way of life of the wider society…” (Jamaica Gleaner – July 24, 2013).  As “good” as that sounds, one cannot help but wonder what the true motive behind this is, considering how vocal civil society and the public in general have been regarding governance in Jamaica in the last year or so.

Then, imagine my shock when news emerged this week that PNPYO Kingston Chapter Chairman, Keron Woods, was suspended for two years for daring to criticize PNPYO President, Alric Campbell for “not consulting with the membership before announcing that the organization did not support a Commission of Enquiry into the 2010 Tivoli Gardens incursion”.  Woods, along with two other members of the PNPYO were not only suspended, but were mandated to do as many as 300 hours of community service.

This is a VERY disconcerting trend!  Why do I get the feeling that dissent is being punished?  That if one disagrees with “The Party” they are sidelined for their views?  Is the Government of Jamaica attempting to police public opinion?

The irony is that all this is unfolding as we prepare to commemorate “Emancipendence”.  It appears that independent thinking and freedom of opinion are slowly slipping through our fingers.

Are Jamaicans really going to sit by and let this happen?


“There are only two choices: A police state in which all dissent is suppressed or rigidly controlled; or a society where law is responsive to human needs. If society is to be responsive to human needs, a vast restructuring of our laws is essential.
Realization of this need means adults must awaken to the urgency of the young people’s unrest—in other words there must be created an adult unrest against the inequities and injustices in the present system. If the government is in jeopardy, it is not because we are unable to cope with revolutionary situations. Jeopardy means that either the leaders or the people do not realize they have all the tools required to make the revolution come true. The tools and the opportunity exist. Only the moral imagination is missing.”

– William O. Douglas, 1970

@MizDurie, @THINKJamaica

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Jamaica in “1984”

  1. Iam Jev says:

    Can you imagine Durie? The PNP Government that trumpets freedom and equality has tossed their mission aside. I dont know what this is but until we are able to know of the political parties campaign source of funding and see reports of minutes that the Govt had with countries like Cuba then Civil Society should forever hold out on this proposal.

    • thinkjamaica says:

      Thanks for reading and giving your feedback. It is a very serious issue! We can hardly get comments from government officials on pressing issues, but now everyone else should remain silent? It doesn’t make sense.

  2. Richie says:

    So, what do we do about this?
    I know for a fact that unity is strength, unless Jamaicans unite against this tyranny which we’ve been living under for ever so long, it will only change for the worst. So, isn’t our challenge going to be getting the people to unite?

    • thinkjamaica says:

      Thanks for reading, Richie. Sadly, with a society so politically polarized, it will be a challenge in getting people to even see the problem here, much more unite around a common cause.

  3. Double A says:

    Most people are afraid. I saw this firsthand in university. No matter what foolishness the administration meted out, students would only complain within themselves, but no one was brave enough to take action, and though we tout the maxim “unity is strength” we aren’t brave enough to try it, and any single person who tried was shut down. Everybody fears their personal safety and repercussions from speaking out, so we just take the foolishness. I’m not a fan of war, but I kinda wish some of the mentality of the people in Egypt have (so much so to oust a president!) would rub off on us so we can actually do something about this rubbish that’s going on!

    Twas a good read, Durie 🙂

  4. Rodje Malcolm says:

    “Blind belief in authority is the greatest enemy of truth” – Einstein

    Great analysis! Very relevant too. The tribalism and “run with it” blind loyalty that many Jamaicans have betrays a preoccupation with party, ego and power and less with nation building. When dissent becomes labelled as “unpatriotic,” it highlights a troubling trend. True patriotism puts truth over tribe and is not concerned with image. A democracy without dissent is a failed democracy.

    Benjamin Franklin once said, “If everyone is thinking alike, then no one is thinking.”

  5. Pingback: Beauty Queen Politics | CucumberJuice

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s